I was 21 years old the last time the New York Mets won a World Series. At the time, I couldn’t have imagined 21 years later, the ’86 championship would still be their most recent. While a drought of such length hardly compares to what other teams’ fans have put up with, there’s a definite sense this morning a window of opportunity has closed, one that cannot so easily be reopened in 2008.
For all the talk of what David Wright, Jose Reyes and (just maybe) Lastings Milledge might mean long-term, these Mets were assembled to win now. Even assuming the likes of Tom Glavine, Paul Lo Duca or Carlos Delgado come back in ’08 (hardly sure things in any case), they’re all another year older. As will be the oft-injured Moises Alou, Orlando Hernandez and that promising September call-up, Pedro Martinez.
We’ll never know how the ’07 Mets would’ve faired in the playoffs —- keep in mind that last season’s 85 win Cardinals slumped in September and put the fear of god into none of their playoff opponents — but with all due respect to the Phillies, the Mets’ failure to win one more game during the campaign’s final week still borders on the unbelievable. Evan Roberts, the master of understatement, called this “the biggest choke job in the history of regular season sports”, and when you consider the way the Mets were manhandled at home by Washington and Florida, two bad teams with nothing to play for, it’s very tough to argue with the WFAN mid-morning howler.
Keep in mind this sort of collapse isn’t supposed to happen to a team with an ample supply of veteran leadership. Every single member of the everyday lineup, is a former All-Star with postseason experience. That clubhouse included owners of World Series rings such as Glavine, Martinez, El Duque, Jeff Conine and Luis Castillo. Not to mention those championships won during Willie Randolph, Rickey Henderson or Howard Johnson’s playing days.
Just as there are few precedents for a collapse of this magnitude, it’s not as you could claim the club was lacking in “character guys” or some such nonsense. But even the most casual observer had to note the palpable sense of dread surrounding the Mets over the final week, compared to downright giddy approach of 2 teams a combined 40 games under .500. I usually don’t put much stock in notions that accomplished veterans need a Larry Bowa-type to get on their ass when things become a tad sloppy, but I also thought this Mets roster — flawed though it was in spots (and the Phillies pitching staff didn’t have holes?) — should’ve been good enough to at least win 90 games.
Here’s a few quotes to ponder from around this morning’s sobby blogosphere :
I never liked this team. Early on, when they were ahead of last year’s pace, I was vaguely embarrassed by this. Like a lot of us, I found myself groping for explanations, and worrying about why they left me cold. Was this the ugly side of raised expectations? Of the first stages of hegemony? Was this how being a Yankee fan began? What wasn’t to like?
But I struggled to warm to them during the spring, and when they stumbled through the summer I stopped fighting it. I let a bit of hard-earned cynicism take over, dissecting fandom like social scientists examine human attachment. I told myself that when they made the playoffs, I’d find myself liking them just fine. But then the second half of September came, with the second horrible body blow administered by the Phillies, the inept handling of the pitching staff, the idiotic displays of temper, and the repeated assheaded baseball. And finally, those horrifying quotes by Delgado and Glavine and Pedro, the astonishing admissions that yeah, the team was bored and complacent. That right there was the end of the pretending that I would change my mind. – Jason, Faith & Fear In Flushing
For a franchise that gave us the Terry Pendelton home run, the Mike Scioscia home run, the Worst Team Money Could Buy, Bobby Valentine’s fake mustache, a bases loaded walk to end a playoff series, the 2000 Subway Series, eighteen Brian Jordan grand slams, countless losses to Atlanta, trading a number one prospect who would one day lead the American League in strikeouts for a guy who ran off the field with an arm injury never to be seen at Shea Stadium again, a game seven loss to an 83 victory St. Louis Cardinal team that had no business getting as far as they did, you…the 2007 New York Mets…have done the impossible.
You topped ’em all.
You allowed a man who once punched his wife with a closed fist on a Boston street throw his glove in the air and feel feelings that I should have been feeling tonight.
You proved right a man who made a stupid statement at the beginning of the season when he said “finally, we have the best team on paper.” I said then that Jimmy Rollins was wrong, and I still say he’s wrong. The Philadelphia Phillies did not have the best team on paper. The New York Mets, however, did.
But guess what the Philadelphia Phillies are: They’re the best team in the National League East. And that’s what counts. – Metsradamus
The people that run SportsNet New York have, in their two years of existence, proven to be absolutely clueless about their primary audience, the Mets fan. Without us, this network has virtually no reason to exist. Unfortunately, the suits in command of this vehicle have no loyalty at all to Mets fans. Their decision to forgo pre- and post-game shows during the September pennant race for all games televised on Channel 11 or FOX was indefensible enough, but to provide absolutely nothing today with the entire season riding on the outcome was utterly inexcusable. They gave us nothing… nada… zip… bupkis.
Whatever else you might say about YES and NESN, they’re always there for Yankee and Red Sox fans when it matters. Jeers to this joke of a network, which puts much more effort into trying to appeal to non-Mets fans than to serving us. Disgraceful. – Mike Steffanos, Mike’s Mets
These Phillies didn™t exactly lack for self-help. Gallant and resilient in ways the Mets proved not to be, their back-to-back series sweeps of the Mets did plenty to fracture the Mets™ spines. Their own didn™t buckle, even when the first of their two sweeps of the Mets saw the Mets go on a small but profound enough tear to leave at least one or two Phillies ready to concede the Mets the East. But there probably isn™t a Phillie to be found who thought they™d get such monumental help from such a source as the Mets themselves.
The Mets finally failed in their apparent and insane quest to prove that you could lock up a division championship by playing most of the final month like you 1962 ancestors”twelve losses in the final seventeen games and 21 errors on that ledger”and not even being half as funny about it. – Jeff Kallman, Catbird In The Nosebleed Seats
They overcame a terrible start, a barrage of injuries, pitching meltdowns by the dozen and some of the most harrowing, horrifying losses I can remember. They did it with the most potent offense they’ve ever mustered, led by a leadoff man whose power and speed would have made his hero, Rickey Henderson, proud–even if Rickey’s currently changing into street clothes in a funereal Shea Stadium clubhouse. Backing him up was a second baseman who might be the most complete hitter in the game, a slugger from Central Casting who homered in five of the team’s last six games, a centerfielder who hit .310 and proved he was more than a bloody face, and a left fielder who went from Public Enemy No. 1 to second-half savior.
And they owe a lot of this to the inarticulate but indomitable manager who never stopped believing in them. – The Good Phight
By now, you™ll know whether Billy Wagner was a hero, a goat, or a merely a bystander in the final act of this historic meltdown. But as he sat in the dugout last week, speaking evenly in his lilting southern accent, Billy Wagner reminded me of those Confederate soldiers in Ken Burns™s Civil War documentary: honorable, defiant, and quite possibly doomed. – Chris Smith, New York Magazine
Is this the worst season in Mets history? Worse than losing last year to the Cards? Worse than losing to the Yankees in 2000? Worse than Kenny Rogers walking in the eliminating run in 99? Worse than losing the final 5 games to miss the playoffs in 98? Worse than Orel Herschiser making the team’s offense look totally inept in the 88 playoffs. Worse than all the terrible sub-.500 seasons in between?
Yeah, I think it is.
I too fully expected to the team to win 90 plus. Probably not as many as last year but around 92 or 93. However, after watching this teams pathetic final two weeks and I almost hoped they wouldn’t make the playoffs. The way they were playing they wouldn’t get very far anyway. If they’re eliminated now or a week from now, what’s the difference besides sparing me another week of torment?
On the bright side, I’m no longer obligated to see Dane Cook in an MLB promo.
What scares me the most if that the Mets don’t really have much in home grown pitching to replace El Duque, Glavine, whomever. Trading Brian Bannister, Henry Owens, Matt Lindstrom, Heath Bell, etc was a series of big mistakes.
The Mets might have the largest stockpile of broken arms in the minors though with Burgos, Sanchez, and Padilla heading up the collection. And they mentioned during yesterday’s broadcast that Jason Vargas is undergoing surgery too.
I’m hoping that Pelfrey and Humber figure it out over the off season, because there’s not much out there for the Mets to sign.
i don’t remember as many blowouts down the stretch in ’98 but I was drinking heavily that week.
i don’t disagree with you in the slightest, Marc, but name me one person in April who thought the Mets would deeply regret losing Brian Bannister.
If the Mets are serious about replacing Glavine and El Duque in the rotation with Pelfrey and Humber, they can forget about contending in ’08. Which might be for the better, anyway.
As a Giants fan, I think we would be happy to take Da Edge off your hands for, say, Noah Lowry?
i certainly didn’t think losing Bannister in April was a big deal, but I thought it was weird to lose him for what we got. Bannister seemed like a solid back of the rotation guy and since Burgos seemed like Jorge Julio v2.0, I was a bit confused. Especially since everyone was saying our starting pitching was suspect and the bullpen was not in spring training.
The Heath Bell trade irks me mostly because we got crap for him. Ben Johnson was not Xavier Nady v2.0 (ie, someone who had be projected to be a lot better than what his stats said, if he could fix some holes in his swing). Between him, Julio Franco, and David Newhan, it was like our bench/reserve outfielders were destined to be crap. Thank god Damien Eisley and then Marlon Anderson came along.
I suppose if the Mets can get through the first couple of months with Humber/Pelfrey, then maybe Mulvey can be a late summer callup? I have no problem with El Duque coming back, though maybe a bullpen roll is more appropriate for him at this point.
It’ll be an interesting off season to say the least.
In the meantime, I’m rooting for the Indians — not because I want the Yankees eliminated (which I do), but because they’re an original team, they haven’t won in decades, and I can’t think of ANYONE on that team that really bothers me.
Now you know what we mean when we say being a Cub fan builds character. Get over it. Ten more of these will make men out of you. 20 more gets you that 1000 yard stare. 30 more and you get to be called “lovable” by the whole league.
Btw, the wildly East Coast bias on this blog failed to even note the big upset yesterday, that the first place Cubs were beaten by the basement dwelling Reds.
Ben
I think I wrote something here when they traded away Bannister (*toots own horn*). I didn’t know that Henry Owens came from the Mets’ farm system, so now I’m thinking that Omar is much worse at making trades than I had previously thought (he’s closing in on Steve Phillips territory). A lot of good teams have good young pitching on the horizon (Red Sox, Yankees, Dodgers…) and it makes me wonder if the Mets will have to go the expensive free agent route in order to compete (since they traded all of the good ones). Omar’s been the toast of the town since he got here, but he needs to put away that phoney grin, roll up his sleeves and really get to work. Start by hiring better scouts so that they don’t blow the next amateur draft. And quit signing guys over the age of 40 (though I’m sure he’s already thinking about making Curt Schilling an offer; that’s his type of move).
Michael,
throw in Zito and half of his salary and we can have a conversation about it.
Rog,
“it makes me wonder if the Mets will have to go the expensive free agent route in order to compete”
Well, thanks. That really cheers me up. Courtesy of MLB Trade rumors, here’s a quick glance at the winter’s free agent crop :
Catchers
Brad Ausmus (39)
Michael Barrett (31)
Ramon Castro (32)
Jason Kendall (34)
Paul Lo Duca (36)
Jorge Posada (36)
Jose Molina (33)
Ivan Rodriguez (36) – $13MM club option for ’08
Yorvit Torrealba (30)
First basemen
Sean Casey (34)
Tony Clark (36)
Adam Dunn (28) – $13MM club option for ’08
Darin Erstad (34) – $3.5MM club option for ’08
Scott Hatteberg (38) – $1.85MM club option for ’08
Ryan Klesko (37)
Mike Lamb (33)
Doug Mientkiewicz (34)
Second basemen
Luis Castillo (32)
Damion Easley (38)
Marcus Giles (30) – $4MM club option for ’08
Tadahito Iguchi (33)
Mark Loretta (37)
Kaz Matsui (32)
Jose Valentin (38)
Shortstops
David Eckstein (33)
Cesar Izturis (28) – $5.45MM club option for ’08
Juan Uribe (29) – $5MM club option for ’08
Omar Vizquel (41)
Third basemen
Pedro Feliz (33)
Mike Lamb (32)
Mike Lowell (34)
Alex Rodriguez (32) – Has ability to opt out of contract after season
Left fielders
Moises Alou (42) – $7.5MM club option for ’08
Barry Bonds (43)
Milton Bradley (30)
Adam Dunn (28) – $13MM club option for ’08; becomes free agent after season if traded
Cliff Floyd (35) – mutual option for ’08
Luis Gonzalez (40)
Geoff Jenkins (33) – $9MM club option for ’08
Reggie Sanders (40)
Shannon Stewart (34)
Brad Wilkerson (31)
Center fielders
Milton Bradley (30)
Mike Cameron (35)
Darin Erstad (34) – $3.5MM club option for ’08
Torii Hunter (32)
Andruw Jones (31)
Kenny Lofton (41)
Corey Patterson (28)
Aaron Rowand (30)
Right fielders
Bobby Abreu (34) – $16MM club option for ’08
Milton Bradley (30)
Kosuke Fukudome (31)
Shawn Green (35) – $10MM club option for ’08
Jose Guillen (32) – $9MM club option for ’08
Geoff Jenkins (33) – $9MM club option for ’08
Trot Nixon (34)
Reggie Sanders (40)
DHs
Barry Bonds (43)
Mike Piazza (39)
Sammy Sosa (39)
Mike Sweeney (34)
Starting pitchers
Tony Armas (30) – $5MM mutual option for ’08
Kris Benson (33) – $7.5MM club option for ’08
Paul Byrd (37) – $8MM club option for ’08
Shawn Chacon (30)
Roger Clemens (46)
Matt Clement (33)
Bartolo Colon (35)
Josh Fogg (31)
Casey Fossum (30)
Freddy Garcia (32)
Tom Glavine (42) – $9MM player option for ’08
Livan Hernandez (33)*
Jason Jennings (29)
Joe Kennedy (29)
Byung-Hyun Kim (29)
Brian Lawrence (32)
Jon Lieber (38)
Kyle Lohse (29)
Rodrigo Lopez (32)
Greg Maddux (42) – $8.75MM player option or $11MM club option for ’08
Eric Milton (32)
Tomo Ohka (32)
Russ Ortiz (34)
Odalis Perez (31) – $9MM club option for ’08
Andy Pettitte (36) – $16MM player option for ’08
Joel Pineiro (29)
Kenny Rogers (43)
Curt Schilling (41)
Carlos Silva (29)
Julian Tavarez (35) – $3.85MM club option for ’08
John Thomson (34)
Brett Tomko (35) – $4.5MM mutual option for ’08
Steve Trachsel (37) – $4.75MM club option for ’08
Koji Uehara (33)
Jeff Weaver (31)
David Wells (45)
Kip Wells (31)
Randy Wolf (31) – $9MM club option for ’08
Jamey Wright (34)
Jaret Wright (32)
Closers
Armando Benitez (35)
Joe Borowski (37) – $4MM club option for ’08
Francisco Cordero (33)
Octavio Dotel (32) – $5.5MM mutual option for ’08
Eric Gagne (32)
Jason Isringhausen (35) – $8MM club option for ’08
Todd Jones (40)
Al Reyes (37) – $1MM club option for ’08
Mariano Rivera (38)
Bob Wickman (39)
Middle relievers
Jeremy Affeldt (29)
Antonio Alfonseca (36)
LaTroy Hawkins (35)
Jorge Julio (29)
Joe Kennedy (29)
Scott Linebrink (31)
Troy Percival (39)
David Riske (31) – $2.85MM club option for ’08
Russ Springer (39)
Julian Tavarez (35) – $3.85MM club option for ’08
Mike Timlin (42)
Luis Vizcaino (31)
Kerry Wood (31)
1) I can fix Casey Fossum in 15 minutes.
2) Still a little too blinded by anger to analyze much, here, but what bugs me most about watching this team fall apart was the fact that while the stars, Reyes excepted and obviously Glavine yesterday, did exactly what was needed, it was the marginal dudes who cost the team big. Which means that the same thing that bugged me about a lot of the Phillips/Duquette moves still holds: in minor fine-tuning deals the team manages to give up big talent (Jason Bay for Steve Reed, for instance?) and littler talent (Lindstrom, Owens, Bell, etc) for not just weak players but for no discernible reason. Burgos has a higher ceiling than Bannister, per scouts, so maybe that makes sense, maybe, but who thought the team needed Jason Vargas? Or Jon Adkins? Or David Newhan? Or, more precisely, who thought they were improvements over the system-bred guys who were already there, and already a part of the team?
As a Mets fan, and as a sentimentalist, I have a certain degree of loyalty to everyone who’s worn the uniform (1993 roster excepted), and so I’m sad to see almost every Met go. But Omar’s disloyalty to his marginal players — the idea that there’s someone out there who can do what, say, Darren Oliver does and that it might be just as well not to have it be Darren Oliver (or Chad Bradford or whomever) — actually made an impact this year. The team didn’t cohere. They couldn’t pitch by the end of the season, either, which was obviously a big deal, but the inability to find that backbone might have something to do with the fact that there’s no core loyalty to anyone beyond the superstars (and Endy and…Julio Franco?). It’s why I think, in the end, I’m a lot more comfortable blaming Minaya than anyone else for the meltdown. His tweaks wound up leading to big problems, and they just didn’t need to be done.
3) I was definitely mad about both the Bel/Ring and Owens/Lindstrom deals. But I also got mad when Gerald Williams was on the roster last year. This is because I am a dork.
Now starting on Opening Day for the New York Mets: Kerry Wood. OMFG that would be a good way to tank the season.