The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s Bob Smizik is of the opinion that enough has already been done to honor the late Roberto Clemente. (link courtesy Repoz and Baseball Think Factory)
At a time when the Pirates blatantly ignore some of their other greats, like Paul Waner, there’s no need to overdo the focus on Roberto Clemente.
But that’s what a group called Hispanics Across America is doing. It is the intent of this group to have Clemente’s number retired by every team in baseball.
The only player in any major professional sport accorded such treatment is Jackie Robinson. It should stay that way.
Fernando Mateo, president of Hispanics Across America, said: “We’re not doing this because he was the first Hispanic player to have 3,000 hits or because he was a 12-time Gold Glove winner or a 12-time All-Star. We’re doing it because of the way he lived his life and the way he died.”
Sorry, even if we actually knew how Clemente led his life, that doesn’t approach the standard Robinson set for number retirement across the sport.
No question, MLB is entirely capable of caving in on this issue since, after all, it’s all about marketing. If it does, will the number of an Asian player be similarly honored? Ten years from now will there be an outcry to retire Ichiro Suzuki’s No. 51?
What about Jewish players, who received heavy doses of anti-Semitism? Will there be a demand to have the number 32 of Sandy Koufax retired in every stadium?
That might sound silly, but no more so than the movement to retire Clemente’s number throughout baseball.
Given that some of today’s players and fans know little of Clemente’s accomplishments on or off the field, I think there’s little danger of “overdoing the focus”. I’m not crazy about every club retiring the same player’s number, but the Ichiro and Koufax comparisons show that Smizik really doesn’t grasp the cultural significance that Clemente holds for many of those old enough to have seen him play.
Reading the Daily News most days (the print version) I see the ad in there constantly urging me to write my Senator or some such. I’m a huge Clemente fan – I really did name my cat “Robie” (short for robot I told the wife, but really with my mind on Clemente). But I wonder if it would be nearly as eye-opening, and possibly more so because it would be annual, if MLB made a conscious effort to make a BIG DEAL out of the Roberto Clemente award they give out each season.
I’m pretty sure I’ve read a couple of books about Clemente, and I’m sure there were a lot of first person accounts of “how Clemente lived his life” – perhaps Mr. Smizik should check into the Pittsburgh Public Library system?
by ” conscious effort to make a BIG DEAL out of the Roberto Clemente award”, isn’t nominating Milton Bradley enough?
Bradley “has paid for youngsters to attend games at Dodger Stadium (the Bradley’s Crew Ticket Program) and has taken part in a number of local school and hospital visits, youth clinics and the Dodger Caravan.”
Seriously though, what if they only gave out the award when a player earned it – instead of nominating players from each team every year, and THEN they made a BIG DEAL about it.
they should retire his number. Not only will this be big for hispanics but it will show the respect that Roberto Clemente deserves. BORICA!!!!!
Hola baseball Fans… Hummm, old but never forgotten conversation i find here. But interesting that the day im looking for information on the men Roberto Clemente i find this dilema. Lets not forget the legacy that a men leaves for the future generations, the examples he left for the young ones to follow. Teachers here in the island schools try to teach this values to the new generations. We need to go past the numbers and look at the big picture and TEACH everyone the way to live a productive life, a life of caring for each other and for those that you dount even know. Love, hope and helping your fellow men even if he is not in your own team or country. Should Dale Earnhardt #3 be retierd? hummm…. my guess its that it wount, his son will pass the legacy of the number and hopefully will make the number shine more for the legacy of the man. So if #21 does or does not get retierd what is to be honor allways and pass along is the legacy of the men, that for more overshadows the number.