(Mets first round draft choice Reese Havens, who apparently, no one has ever heard of before)
“I don™t know Ike Davis or Brad Holt. I didn™t know who David Wright was till he joined the Mets organization. Anyone who gets drafted today most likely won™t be seen at Shea for at least two to three years. So who cares about all the hype, let Omar do his job and wake me up in two years when its time to misspell their names in posts” writes Hot Foot‘s Dan Lerner, an alleged fan that finds the charms of the First Year Player Draft and amateur baseball somewhat elusive.
Its not that I don™t care, well. Not entirely that I don™t care. I understand the importance of restocking the farm system. I grasp that these prospects do in fact come from somewhere. But as far as that process is considered, lets face it, most of you don™t really give a damn. Sure, all six Andrews that write for this site, and that new guy all seem pretty excited. All giggly and giddy like school girls, making their predictions. Me, I couldn™t even name one college baseball player, and I know a guy who plays college baseball.
Here™s the thing. College football has all these long standing traditions (like Duke sucking), and old school rivalries. College basketball has March Madness and young phenoms that will go straight to the NBA after their freshman year. Baseball¦.seriously, can you watch college baseball without physically being at a game? I spent a good, lets call it five, years in college. Baseball games I attended: 0. I even went to more college hockey games. When push comes to shove, no one cares about college baseball. Which means, no one knows college baseball players. So basically, the draft to me is meaningless.
This may come as a minor mind blower to Mr. Lerner, but interest in college baseball is at an all-time high. Whether that’s because the games themselves tend to be pretty exciting (tonight’s NCAA Super Regional between Arizona and Miami is a credible example, televised by an obscure cable network called ESPN) or due to the quick ascent of many college players (Joba Who?) is anyone’s guess, but if indeed, no one cared about college baseball, Baseball America would’ve been outta business a long time ago.
Whether Lerner is just a lazy motherfucker or he lacks the intellectual capacity to put college ballplayers into any context beyond “who gives a shit?” I can’t say for sure. Perhaps the above was an attempt at satire. But many of the same reasons I’m given by devotees of college football and hoops for why those sports are more exciting or “pure” at the amateur level can equally be applied to college baseball. But if one jackass wants to dismiss the legitimate interests of others purely because they’re outnumbered, that’s not merely stupid. It’s downright cowardly.
Having a link for “college baseball being at an all time high” be a stubhub listing w/ General Admissions tickets available for $8.50, isn’t proving much at all.
College Baseball uses metal bats. Thats like having a smaller ball for basketball. Who does that? Women. Watching College Baseball is like watching the WNBA. At least in the farm system you can make Bull Durham jokes.
Not to mention that most of the better prospects are drafted out of high school, not college, so his whole point of “I don’t like the draft because I don’t like college baseball” is sorta meaningless.
Alex,
sorry the stubhub link didn’t illustrate the point well enough, but the CWS is sold out ages in advance. It’s not quite the Final Four, but it’s hardly an event no one cares about.
As far as the metal bats are concerned, I don’t get your basketball analogy. From this perspective, the metal bats put pitchers at a competitive disadvantage (if not in the path of being maimed) — facing metal bats has proven to be not so flimsy preperation for the likes of Chad Cordero, Huston Street or Joba Chamberlain, just to name 3 hurlers who made their way from the draft to the big leagues in rapid succession.
“At least in the farm system you can make Bull Durham jokes.”
Since I’m sure you’d rather offer an informed opinion than just being full of shit in public, how about you spend a week watching D-1 college baseball (you’ll have every opportunity to do so when the CWS starts) and then spend a similar amount of time watching any Class A minor league game. If you don’t think the former compares favorably to the latter, I’ll send you my autographed Lauren Jackson poster.
That Lerner personally doesn’t care for college baseball is not something I’d wanna argue about. It’s a matter of personal opinion, though even in the self-indulgent blogosphere I’d file such a revelation under who-fucking-cares. Dan Lerner doesn’t give a hoot about college baseball. You’re not into the WNBA. Crushing blows for fans of both they will somehow get over.
But when Lerner claims “no one cares about college baseball”, he’s dead wrong. It’s not nearly as popular as college football or basketball, but how is that a measure of a sport’s redeeming qualities?
“most of the better prospects are drafted out of high school, not college”
21 of the first 30 players selected in Thursday’s draft came from college, not high school.
I’ll give the CWS a fair shot, but the metal bat thing.. I can put a ball out of a 350ft park with a metal bat. I couldn’t hit the warning track with a wooden bat. I know they are making the change over soon, once that happens, I’ll have more respect for the sport.
Its not even like the smaller ball analogy.. its more like a lowering the rim analogy.
Alex,
if you’re capable of hitting a ball 350 feet off Brian Matusz, with or without a metal bat, you’re currently in the wrong line of work.
“21 of the first 30 players selected in Thursday’s draft came from college, not high school”
Very true, but that’s a higher number than for previous drafts (16 first round picks in 2007 were high schoolers, for instance).
10 of the top 15 prospects this year (ranked by Baseball America) were high school kids. The overall first and third picks this year were high schoolers. The usual trend has been that the majority of college players are the ones who weren’t regarded highly enough to go straight from high school into rookie ball (same thing with hockey– the best players get drafted out of juniors, while the rest have to shuffle off to college).
Not that any of this takes away from the overall enjoyment level of college baseball, or the fact that the guy who wrote that blog post is a dunce. I’m just saying that when Dan Lerner infers that the Entry Draft is only about college players, he’s dead wrong.
“The usual trend has been that the majority of college players are the ones who weren’t regarded highly enough to go straight from high school into rookie ball (same thing with hockey– the best players get drafted out of juniors, while the rest have to shuffle off to college).”
You’re not incorrect, however there are players who were certainly good enough to be drafted out of high school who’ve pursued college ball, in some cases to improve their negotiating position.
There’s more than one way of looking at it. For instance, I have a hard believing Normar Garciaparra or Jason Varitek wouldn’t have each excelled in the majors without matriculating at Georgia Tech. But their tenures playing for the Yellowjackets certainly contributed to their eventual signing bonuses, if not their overall level of preparation before entering pro ball.
College baseball will never be the lone source for MLB’s talent pool, granted. But a year or two playing for a club w/ national title aspirations compares pretty favorably to a summer in the NY-Penn League. Though we’ll see some guys do both.