…but after reading said body’s Top 50 Sportscasters Of All Time list, you might be excused if from believing the “Rock, Rot & Rule” author had some involvement. Here’s the rundown, as provided by the LA Times’ Tom Hoffarth :
1 – Vin Scully
2 – Mel Allen
3- Red Barber
4- Curt Gowdy
5- Howard Cosell
6- Bob Costas
7 – Jim McKay
9 – Al Michaels
10 – Dick Enberg
11 – Jack Buck
12 – Ted Husing
14- Don Dunphy
15 – Graham McNamee
16 – Ernie Harwell
17- Marv Albert
18 – Harry Caray
19 – Jon Miller
20 – Bill Stern
21 – Chick Hearn
22- Marty Glickman
23 – Jack Whitaker
24 – Jim Nantz
25- Chris Schenkel
26 – Lindsey Nelson
27 – Russ Hodges
28 – Ray Scott
29 – John Madden
30 – Bob Prince
31- Joe Buck
32 – Milo Hamilton
33- Bob Wolff
34 – Chuck Thompson
35 – Chris Berman
36 – Phil Rizzuto
37 – Marty Brennaman
38 – Clem McCarthy
39 – Bill Walton
40 – Foster Hewitt
41 – Harry Kalas
42 – Johnny Most
43 – Bob Elson
44 – Brent Musberger
45 – Pat Summerall
46 – Merle Harmon
47 – Dick Vitale
48 – Dick Stockton
49 – Tony Kubek
50 – Bud Collins
While some omissions (Bob Gamere, Tony Schiavone) are more excusable than others (Bill King), the prominent placements of the younger Buck and Boomer are right up there with Jethro Tull’s “Best Metal Album” Grammy and Marisa Tomei’s Best Supporting Actress Oscar. The respective fan club presidents for Myron Cope and Joe Bowen have undoubtedly begun their letter writing campaigns ; the same might be said of John Sterling, the only question being whether or not the Yankee mouthpiece will sign his own name.
Has Chris Berman ever called a game? I thought he was a studio guy.
Plus: WHERE THE F-K IS BOB MURPHY?!?!?
surely you’ve heard Berman do baseball play-by-play?
No Hawk Harrelson? What a joke.
Jim Nantz’s presence in the top half of this list must be due to sheer volume, because it sure ain’t for quality (especially nowadays, when he seems to be going for that legacy-making One Shining Moment soundbyte on every play).
Jon Miller gets mid-listed? And Graham Mcnamee? Is there a human within living memory who knows the sound of his voice? Are 200-year-old tortoises allowed votes? I like Scully somewhere near the top, but Bob Costas? And what about Steve Allen’s career calling wrestling? Joey Styles is nowhere to be found? I second Andrew’s comment tho, Hawk Harrelson needs HOF status NOW.
I’ve taken to muting the tv and listening to the radio broadcast whenever Joe Buck is on.
Any list with Milo Hamilton is a crock. Any list without Jack Brickhouse on it is also a crock.
JACK Buck should be in the top ten instead of Costas.
1. Stop slandering Marisa Tomei, she was ON POINT in that movie and you know it. Don’t hate the player, hate the game.
2. NO BOB UECKER NO CREDIBILITY. Anyone who can seamlessly call a pre-season game while threatening to punch an ostrich right in the face (and I have heard this first-hand) deserves a top 10 spot before you even factor in his legendary ‘this is what a sports announcer should be’ movie and TV performances. Shameful…although not as shameful as your in-house Cubs guy/Brewer hater will be about disparaging this comment.