The above image was culled from the front page of Baseball Mr. Faded Glory from High & Tight is slightly more explicit in his criticism of the voting process ;

They award Jeter, when not only do the defensive metrics say the opposite, but even with the naked eye it’s readily apparent that Jeter’s future away from the shortstop position is coming quickly.

He’s obviously lost more than a step and these voters can’t see past the intangibles.